Elkhart denies responsibility in pedestrian deaths

Elkhart Truth file photoDrivers pass by a memorial made in honor of the three individuals killed in a hit-and-run crash near the intersection of Beardsley Avenue and Cassopolis Street in this 2017 photo.

ELKHART — Elkhart is not responsible for pedestrian deaths that happened along Beardsley Avenue in 2017 because the road has not been redesigned in the past 20 years, lawyers for the city say in response to a negligence lawsuit.

The survivors of an Aug. 26, 2017, pedestrian accident and the family of three other people who were killed claim the city was careless and negligent in failing to maintain the sidewalk. They also say in the lawsuit that the city was aware of vehicles driving over the curb at the intersection of Beardsley Avenue and Cassopolis Street in the past.

The suit was filed in February in Elkhart County court by Allison Mikel-Smith and Bradley Smith, who survived the accident, and by the families of the three who were killed. Eight-month-old Dolly Smith, 11-year-old Courtney Smith and 22-year-old Shawn Wolcott died after a vehicle driven by 43-year-old Leonard Grosswiler left the roadway and struck them.

Grosswiler, of Mishawaka, pleaded guilty and received a 15-year sentence. His passenger, 41-year-old Penelope Grosswiler, admitted to helping him cover up the crime by cleaning and hiding the vehicle, and was sentenced to two-and-a-half years.

City’s response

In its response to the lawsuit, lawyers for Elkhart deny allegations that the deaths and injuries were a direct result of negligence by the city. 

They deny that the city acted negligently in failing to maintain the sidewalk or to provide warning signs ahead of the lane reduction at the intersection. They also deny the allegation that the city was aware of a recurring problem with vehicles failing to negotiate the lane transition and driving over the curb and onto the sidewalk in the same area where Grosswiler struck the pedestrians.

The response was filed in April on behalf of the city by attorneys with a Schererville law firm.

It also includes a number of points in defense of the city, such as a claim that Elkhart is immune from the lawsuit because the accident occurred at least 20 years after the section of road was designed.

“(T)he intersection of East Beardsley Avenue and Cassopolis Street, the section of East Beardsley Avenue in the immediate vicinity of the accident, as well as the sidewalks located at the intersection of East Beardsley Avenue and Cassopolis Street and on East Beardsley Avenue in the immediate vicinity of the accident have not been designed or substantially redesigned within the past twenty years, and therefore defendant is entitled to immunity under” Indiana law, the filing states.

The response also claims the plaintiffs may have voluntarily assumed the risk and may have contributed by their own negligence.

(1) comment

Betty Zeta

WOW! IMP, it matters NOT when that section was redone or not. It still remains unsafe and if I read my Indiana code right, PROPERLY maintaining of streets and sidewalks fall to the street department RUN BY THE CITY. The city's attitude and response to this is NOT reflecting a 'City with a Heart'. JMO

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.