Thursday, October 23, 2014
Loading...





Judge tosses suit claiming botched circumcision

Alabama judge dismiss lawsuit claiming botched circumcision, penis amputation at hospital

Posted on Aug. 7, 2014 at 12:00 a.m. | Updated on Aug. 7, 2014 at 8:09 p.m.

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (AP) — A judge threw out a lawsuit filed by an Alabama man who claims a botched circumcision resulted in the amputation of his penis, ruling Thursday that the complaint wasn’t specific under state malpractice law.

Jefferson County Circuit Judge Jim Hughey III ruled after a brief hearing that the suit filed Johnny Lee Banks Jr. and his wife lacked sufficient details but could be filed again to include specific times and dates of alleged actions.

Banks, 59, has numerous health problems including diabetes that have led to the amputation of his legs. He left the courtroom in tears in a wheelchair after talking with his lawyer, John Graves.

“It’s a terrible, terrible tragedy what my client has gone through,” Graves told the judge.

The judge gave the man 30 days to file an amended lawsuit, which Graves said he planned to do.

Banks and his wife last month sued Princeton Baptist Medical Center in Birmingham plus Drs. Michael Bivins and Alan Aikens and their employers. Banks alleges that he awoke from what was supposed to be a routine circumcision in June to realize his penis was gone.

Attorneys for the doctors and hospital contend the medical procedure alleged in the suit never happened and predicted the lawsuit will be dismissed again if Banks pursues the claim.

The defense filed sworn statements from two nurses who said Banks had a circumcision at the hospital in February, months before he claimed in the suit, but there was no record of any amputation.

Mike Florie, an attorney representing the doctors, said Banks has “massive health problems” including diabetes, kidney failure and heart disease. The circumcision in February resulted from circulatory problems linked to diabetes but wasn’t performed by either of the doctors named in Banks’ suit, Florie said.

“The surgery that’s alleged simply never took place,” said Florie.

The hospital’s lawyer, Jay Juliano, said the suit had smeared the name of the medical center and requested records only days before filing the complaint.

Graves said he now has as many as 4,000 pages of medical records but could file a revamped lawsuit quickly.

The defense also is seeking professional sanctions against Banks’ lawyer for filing what it claims is a frivolous lawsuit, but the judge said the request was premature.


Recommended for You


 This Wednesday, Oct. 22, 2014, photo shows the apartment complex in Aurora, Colo., which police say is the home of one of the three teenage girls who, according to U.S. authorities, were en route to join the Islamic State group in Syria when they were stopped at an airport in Germany. The two sisters, ages 17 and 15, and their 16-year-old friend have been reunited with their families in Colorado, according to an FBI spokeswoman. (AP Photo/Brennan Linsley)

Posted 1 hour ago
 FILE - In this Oct. 9, 2014, file photo, Navajo presidential candidate Chris Deschene speaks to supporters in Window Rock, Ariz. Deschene has lost another round in a language fluency dispute, all but ending his bid for office. The tribe's high court on Wednesday, Oct. 22, 2014, upheld a ruling from a lower court that said Deschene is not qualified to seek the top elected post because he doesn't speak fluent Navajo. (AP Photo/Felicia Fonseca, File)

Posted 1 hour ago
 Rob Olson of Erkelens & Olsen Auctioneers displays Rulon Gardner's memorabilia at his auction house Wednesday, Oct. 22, 2014, in Salt Lake City. Mementos from the career of Olympic hero Rulon Gardner, including a USA Wrestling robe and a commemorative ring, will be auctioned off Saturday Oct. 25, 2014 in Salt Lake City. Next to it are dozens of medals the Greco-Roman wrestler won during his career, countless knives and watches. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)

Posted 1 hour ago
Back to top ^